Bases loaded 1-2-3 DP

[iscore@tragus.org]

Our boys got a nice double-play this afternoon that left me scratching my head to figure out the right sequence for scoring.

Bases are loaded with one out.
Batter hits a grounder to the pitcher.
Pitcher lobs it to the catcher who tags home for a force out on the runner at 3rd.
Catcher throws to first for the double play.

Here's how I scored it:
In Play -> Fielder's Choice
Ball went to the pitcher
Next
P-C-1B Done
What happened to the runner on third base: Out -> Force Out
What happened to the runner on second base: Held Up at Third
What happened to the runner on second base: Held Up at Second
What happened to the batter: Out -> Double Play
The scorecard shows the batter out between 1st and 2nd which isn't really right.

I thought about it later and did it this way in a test game:
Out -> Ground Out
Ball went to the pitcher
Next
P-C-1B Done
What happened to the runner on third base: Out -> Double Play
That looks right on the scorecard but my taps are out of sequence with what actually happened (though I'm the only one who would ever know).

I think the first approach is more correct since it was technically a Fielder's Choice that they managed to turn into a Double Play but I'm bothered that the scorecard shows the batter/runner out between 1st and 2nd rather than on his way to 1st.

Ideally I would like to have been able to do this:
Out -> Double Play
Ball went to the pitcher
Next
P-C-1B Done
Out -> Double Play
But 'Double Play' isn't available until after the first out of the play is recorded.

So... am I being too OCD about the sequence of events? Which alternative would *you* choose?

[TexasRebel]

see my post on the enhancements board...

i had both a 5-2-3 DP and a 4U-3 DP that I could not correctly score today.

[iscore@tragus.org]

Yes, I read through that thread before I posted mine. Your first scenario is almost identical to what we had happen. I decided to post over here in case anyone in the future runs across something similar. Between the two they should find one of the conversations

For anyone looking, here's the Enhancements thread we're talking about: viewtopic.php?f=4&t=1751" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;