RP3 was the most effective reliever by any metric - runs, earned runs, baserunners allowed - so he gets it.

Thanks for the responses.

Scheduled 7 inning game, 4 pitchers were used. Team in question took the lead in the first inning and led the entire game. Starter went three innings. Allowed 1 run, unearned. Reliever #1 went two innings. Allowed 4 runs, all earned. Reliever #2 went one innings. Allowed 1 run, earned. Reliever #3 e...